A losing game: plant-based products attempting to mimic meat and dairy nutritional qualities

It’s time plant-based manufacturers stop talking about the healthy nutrients that plants don’t have and focus on those they do have, says influential Wageningen food scientist Atze Jan van der Goot.

Plant-based products cannot match – and don’t have to match – the health benefits that red meat consumption brings to a balanced and healthy diet, the Professor of Protein Structuring and Sustainability at Wageningen University said at the recent Plant-Based Protein Manufacturing Summit in Amsterdam

Instead of aiming to mimic the healthy nutrients found in meat, said van der Goot, plant-based products should focus on those healthy nutrients only found in plants.

On top of the issues of price, taste and texture​, the nutritional credentials are a challenge for the plant-based sector.

The food industry has witnessed the proliferation of new plant-based meat and dairy substitutes that aim to mimic the organoleptic properties of their conventional counterparts, and are often presented as healthier than animal-based products. But this view is getting pushback from those who suggest many analogue products are unhealthy ultra-processed foods, lacking the health benefits that red meat consumption brings to a balanced and healthy diet

As an example, take meat alternative Heura’s new technology, recently announced, aiming to boost the protein content of its products so that it surpasses their meat equivalents

‘Stop comparing plant-based products to meat’

But the plant-based sector is wrong to concentrate its efforts on attempting to mimic the nutritional benefits available from meat and dairy, said Van der Goot.

The target market for the vast majority of these products, he explained, are flexitarians: those looking to cut down on meat and dairy for health, ethical or environmental reasons. They are therefore already getting the ‘nutritional hit’ of meat and dairy. They don’t need it from plant proteins aside.

This fact offers the plant-based sector a ‘golden opportunity’, he said, to focus on those health benefits only available in wholegrains, fruit, vegetables, legumes, nuts and seeds.

“I think if the focus is on mimicking the nutritional treats of meat or cheese via plant-based products, then you’re playing a losing game. You’ll always get the criticism that the bioavailability is not as high as the supplemented one, or you’re compromising because the protein is not high enough, or you get complaints the product is highly processed.

The debate about the nutritional quality of meat and dairy versus their plant-based equivalents is timely. The FAO, for example, recently admitted that meat, eggs and milk play a ‘vital’ role ​ in meeting global nutrition targets. It added that at a global level, plant-based foods may not provide sufficient nutrition to achieve public health targets.

The infamous planetary health diet featured in the 2019 Eat-Lancet report, due for a second airing next year, has also received much pushback because of the low amount of animal source foods. It therefore fails to provide those vitamins and minerals​ – including iron, zinc, calcium and vitamin B12 – needed to nourish the global population

“I think we really have to re-think the place and role and nutritional value of those [plant-based food] products,” continued Van der Goot.

“First of all, we should get rid of the protein transition term. I think the emphasis on protein makes it really difficult for plant-based companies to compete with meat and dairy.”

Instead, argued the food scientist, those regularly eating meat and dairy products “will benefit from a different nutritional pattern rich in vitamins; rich in phenolic compounds; rich in other minerals which are present in plants but not present in meat”.

This nutritional focus, he claimed, would also allow manufacturers to justify the premium that the plant-based sector currently carries.

Source: FoodNavigator.com

Related reading:

Plant‑Based Protein Manufacturing Summit spotlights growing appetite for animal and dairy-free alternatives

The Plant‑Based Protein Manufacturing Summit in Amsterdam (April 12-13) highlighted that plant-based continues in an upwards trajectory, with companies needing to produce more to satiate consumer demand.

“Despite the bad news cycle, the plant-based segment as a whole and plant-based meat in particular continues to grow steadily and across many geographies,” Miguel Angelo De Facci de Oliveira, COO at Novameat, said at the event. 

Last year, there were concerns about a potential plateau in plant-based foods. Moreover, Innova Market Insights reveals that the growth in plant-based product purchases did slow down, but only in North America – with value growth predicted to decrease by 0.2% CAGR between 2021 and the end of this year. 

Nonetheless, the plant-based sector is growing in value by a forecasted 6.8% and 10.4% for West Europe (CAGR 2021-2023). 

Innova Market Insights Top Ten Trend “Plant-Based: Unlocking a New Narrative,” highlights how the rapid rise of the plant-based sector has, almost inevitably, hit some roadblocks, necessitating a refocus around consumer demands for high-quality, flavourful products. …. Read more here