08 Jul 11 US: Food companies sneak in the veggies
It looks like Kraft Macaroni & Cheese, and Kraft says it tastes just like the original. But a new ingredient is lurking inside this version of the American family dinner staple — cauliflower. But don’t tell the kids!
Kraft Foods is the latest large food manufacturer to try hiding additional veggies in packaged foods, an effort to ride a renewed interest in healthy eating to fatter profits. It’s a slowly growing trend, and it’s one that is dividing food industry experts.
In June, Wal-Mart and Target stores started stocking Kraft Macaroni & Cheese Dinner Veggie Pasta across the country, alongside boxes of the traditional recipe and other alternative versions, including organic and whole grain. Every neon-orange cup serving of the new recipe packs a half-serving of cauliflower.
Kraft joins brands such as ConAgra Foods’s Chef Boyardee, which includes enough tomato in some of its canned pasta to claim half a cup of vegetables per serving, and Unilever’s Ragu pasta sauces, which says it has two servings of veggies for every half cup of sauce.
In the Kraft product, the company freeze-dries cauliflower and pulverizes it into a powder, then uses that powder to replace some of the flour in the pasta.
“We know moms are always looking to please their kids and wanting to not make meals a big ordeal, insofar as being able to get them to eat their food,” said Alberto Huerta, who oversees the Kraft Macaroni & Cheese brand at Kraft. “Mom is looking for ways to sneak veggies into her kids’ diet.”
In Canada, the cauliflower-based pasta has been available since last March. It immediately became one of the faster-selling versions of the dish, Huerta said. It also drew new Kraft Dinner consumers, boosting overall revenue growth for the entire product line.
Kraft’s move is a variation on a theme espoused by several recent — and highly successful — cookbooks. Missy Chase Lapine is author of the “Sneaky Chef” series of cookbooks, in which she promotes a system of colour-coded, pureed fresh and frozen fruits and vegetables that can be mixed into foods such as macaroni and cheese (yams or cauliflower), spaghetti (carrots and sweet potato) and brownies (baby spinach and blueberries).
“The ideal, of course, is you steam up some local, organic, freshly picked cauliflower, and your child eats it outright with a little mist of olive oil, happily,” Lapine said.
But like Kraft, Lapine takes a practical approach. “Food is only healthy if you can get someone to eat it,” she said.
Harry Balzer, who tracks Americans’ eating patterns for The NPD Group, a market research firm, says parents are making genuine attempts to get healthier foods into their kids. Fruits now make up 6 percent of kids’ diets, the largest share since he started tracking kids’ consumption 30 years ago. Meantime, cookies, cake, pre-sweetened cereal, candy and carbonated soft drinks are at their lowest level, in terms of their share of kids’ diets.
But vegetables, which peaked as a percentage of kids’ diets in 1984, remain a sticking point. They’re a hassle for parents to buy and keep fresh, they’re not generally seen as snack foods the way fruits are, and they’re rarely served alone as a main dish. That means if someone is cooking at home, vegetables are added work. And when they are available, many kids simply aren’t biting, the analyst said.
And while parents may have good intentions to buy healthier options, a higher vegetable content doesn’t top the list of criteria.
“I don’t think there’s a food company in American that doesn’t have on its radar the health and wellness of Americans, as a market,” Balzer said. “They think it’s a driving force in our behavior. I know it’s not. I know the driving force of our behaviour is taste buds.”
For Phil Lempert, another food industry analyst, half a serving of cauliflower in the new Kraft Macaroni & Cheese is better than nothing if Americans are willing to serve it.
“I don’t care about the top one percent that can buy whatever they want, eat strictly organic, buy artisan cheese where they know the cheese maker,” Lempert said. “I want to make sure people who go in every week in the supermarket, are spending 22 minutes and 100 bucks a week for a family of four get the best health, taste and value that they can.”
That approach draws skepticism from Marion Nestle, a professor at New York University’s department of nutrition, food studies and public health. Nutrients are lost when vegetables are freeze-dried, Nestle says, and people are also losing the benefit of greater volume of less calorie-dense food in a meal.
“Oh, what will they think of next,” Nestle said. “What a silly idea,” she said.
What does Bob Messenger have to say….
Kraft Mac & Cheese and … Cauliflower? Yikes!
I’ve been thinking more and more about the decision by Kraft Foods to add cauliflower to its iconic Kraft Mac & Cheese. I don’t doubt that Kraft thinks this is a nifty move or they wouldn’t have done it. The cauliflower-infused variation has been on sale in Canada since March and the company says it has done very well. So be it. But I’m sitting here and wondering — is this the future of food? Marketers sneaking veggie ingredients into traditional brands we know and love just to meet a pro-veggie criteria pushed by by the Health Police and supported by government bureaucrats?
I’m thinking yes, because it is almost impossible to get kids to not just eat, but ‘like’ vegetables. Hell, it’s almost as hard to get adults to eat vegetables, no less kids. Vegetables are not fun foods, and, tastewise, they’re not exactly hot dogs and hamburgers. So, apparently, Kraft and other industry marketers will try to sneak in veggies as part of the ingredient mix in popular products, like Mac & Cheese. Well, okay, but here’s a fair warning — kids better not be able to taste them. These veggie ingredients better be so well-hidden that they aren’t detectable sliding over our taste buds.
New York University professor Marion Nestle thinks the whole thing is peculiar. “Oh, what will they think of next…What a silly idea.” Maybe, maybe not. The way I see it, no harm, no foul, I guess, if the tastes we are familiar with are not compromised. Which doesn’t mean I don’t think Kraft Mac & Cheese w/cauliflower isn’t a strange combination.
Bob Messenger is a foremost US food industry commentator and publishes a daily e-zine, The Morning Cup